stains off the sanctuary floor 420… HA! HA! HA! HA!

I totally agree with your statement about it being a stupid major. However, is it possible this degree is about developing social and mentoring skills? I don’t know anything about this particular major so I’m just throwing it out there.

whoa! little bit of sarcasm there?

anywho, while i am not one for fighting over this topic (i wrestle with it myself) i do feel the need to offer a counterpoint, as i am someone who does hold a bachelor’s degree in student ministry.

i cannot speak for colleges outside of geneva college (located in beaver falls, pa), but my own experience and degree i feel are worth the time and money spent on them. we took such classes as methods of student ministry where we dissected various models and discovered strengths and weaknesses of each one. we had a practicum where we were required to be involved in a ministry a minimum of 10 - 15 hours a week and then used the practicum to network and discuss experiences and learn from each other. we took courses on teaching scripture (to any age, but specifically to the not-quite-fully developed adolescent mind). we took contemporary adolescent culture where we were taught methods of apprehending youth culture to point towards christ.

we were also required theology courses, philosophy courses, and being a liberal arts school, general knowledge courses (science, english,speech etc.). we were also given the opportunity to experience real community, within the major and within smaller groups that we joined through the major. we were provided with mentorship through our own experiences, and had professors and upperclassmen to walk with us as we trained.

all in all, i do agree that we should not segregate teens, but it is important i believe to train ourselves in the best methods of reaching them where they are at in order to bring them forward. clark is a great resource. as are doug fields, dan kimball and tony jones (though i do not quite agree with him on everything theologically).

if there is one thing i would add to the student ministries curriculum that is not currently there it would be practical counseling training. i do wish i had added more electives in that vein than i took.

and please do not misinterpret me, i feel that volunteers are the backbone of any solid youth ministry, those who hold a degree and those who do not. some of the most influential youth leaders i ever had did not have a degree in youth ministry.

[...] a fight? 3 07 2007 Stuart has a post up today calling youth ministry degrees to the carpet. He sees them as unnecessary and [...]

Stuart,

I didn’t major in youth ministry (unless you call growing up as a YFC brat) but I think there are some benefits of the degree for some. I took a few classes in Seminary in youth ministry and they helped me. But nothing beats hands on experience.

Chap Clark does have a doctorate in Youth Ministry. Getting a degree doesn’t make you automatically an expert in youth ministry though. Nothing can replace learning by experience and yes you do need to have people skills and the right heart for the Lord and kids. Education has value, but the practical experience does speak volumes to anyone who aspires to have youth ministry as a calling.

Stu,
If I can call you that and pick a fight on top of your fight. I know people who would agree with you that there is no such thing as “youth pastor” in the bible. In fact they would go so far as to say there is no special “pastor” position in the Bible. (Worship, Executive, etc.) but then those same people turn around and say that women cannot fill those roles because women shouldn’t be in leadership (a view I do not hold in it’s traditional moorings). To me those views seem contradictory. If the office of youth, worship, or whatever isn’t addressed in Scripture we cannot use Scripture to in effect discriminate against women. Right?

Stuart,
I think what those of us in youth ministry need is more training in educational methods and theory, and of course these learnings would be useful with all ages we might serve within the church. In particular, current brain research is providing a wealth of information about the best ways that people learn. The seminary I attended had multiple courses in Christian education, but only one January term (4 week) course on youth ministry, and the majority of students did not take this class.

Hey Stuart,

I’ll go one further and say that degrees and majors are waste of time for all - not just youth. I seriously reckon man places way too much attention on such meaningless activities.

Driscoll says that 1,500 seminary trained pastors leave the church each week due to burnout etc. You could have college degress till you’re blue in the face. But if you haven’t got a heart sold out for Jesus, then it’s no point.

Look at Jesus. He used a couple of fishermen, tax collectors and their brothers. Not one “teacher of the law” was to be found.

hahahah,

Whadda ya mean they don’t need no degrees…how else are they gonna convince the youth’s parents that they are qualified to confuse…oops babysit oops I mean teach their kids. LOL

This was a good post!

I’m currently a youth pastor in Seattle and I’ve noticed a trend in my first two years. Church’s figure that if they have a qualified youth pastor that creates a quality youth group or even youth church that this will grow the kingdom of God. This model has killed the church in this area and much of this country. Kids graduate and they feel that the church cannot supply there need for edgy music, chubby bunny, and all nighters because they were taught that its about a group and not about God. I feel like the core of the problem is the lack of understanding of the church. Churches across the country are dying because they refuse to change with the culture. In order to reach the dying churches we need to place a larger emphasis on reaching young people without “youth group”!

So I strongly disagree with your statements. yes the act of seconalizing youth within ministry is not always ag reat idea, but think about it, when in seminary to be a pastor you dont take classes based on youth culture. In those classes you focus on the 22+ aged people, and this is no secret. how can you explain without gettin into the culture all the things of Christ? I am in the process of becoming a youth pastor myself, while this offers a bias of sorts, the majority of my classes are teh same ones you have to take as someone seeking a normal pastorate. the onle excpetion is, i take more youth based culture classes. I learn about how to make it applicable to the youth first, and then adults. What the youth of the world care about, is far different from what the rest of the world does. And yes most issues are the same, but the fact of the matter is without the proper training you wont know how to handle them. Saying a youth min major is stupid, is like saying that doctors dont need to be trained for children, or adults, or men, or women even. Thinka bout it, the spiritual life of a person is much harder to deal with than the physical life, if we say that inorder to give the best care for children we need doctors to sepcialize in it, the same thing goes with pastors.

i hear ya and feel ya. however it is not a bad idea to enroll in the academy so a youth pastor can have the ability to think theologically why and how he/she is going to arrange their ministry.

maybe majoring in marketing is the best major, but majoring in ym may not be a bad choice too if one is pursuing a career in ym.

I think that your perspective would change toward this subject if you knew more about people, what youth pastors study, and more about ministry overall. It’s pretty bold to say that youth pastors are stupid especially when you know nothing about them. 93% of people that give their lives to the Lord do it before the age of 19. So yeah.